Batushka: Hospodi (2019)

This is the third different incarnation of a band called Batushka that I have reviewed now.  The first one was a unique group combining Orthodoxy with their particular brand of black metal.  Then, there was a schism and each of the members of the band claimed he kicked the other out of the band.  And then both members attempted to move on, using the band's name.  The last one I reviewed was the one belonging to Krzysztof Drabikowski, who is largely considered the creative force behind the defunct band.  His further effort was an intriguing continuation of the ideas present on the sole release by the band.  This review will cover the band formed by former vocalist Bartłomiej Krysiuk, who was the first of the two to release new music.

Right off the bat, I can tell you there is a different feel to this release.  Whereas the debut was something of a solemn and eerie affair, this release is much more immediate and aggressive.  There is also a significant difference in production, mostly as a result of this album being released by Metal Blade Records.  There are elements of what made the prior incarnation so intriguing present, but by and large, they are not as important to the overall sound.  For instance, there is still chanting at times, but it is generally used as an introduction to the song, or in the backgrounds.

The music on this release is the biggest difference.  Whereas on the prior incarnation, the black metal was more on the atmospheric side, this is significantly more aggressive, more in the vein of a group like Uada or Mgła.  The riffs are much more apparent and fierce, particularly about midway through "Utrenia".  So this album loses some of its subtlety and becomes more of a standard black metal album, that happens to share some qualities that the earlier incarnation had.  I am not sure that is necessarily a bad thing, but it may not be what was expected in the band had been able to continue.

I see a lot of negative reviews for this album, essentially calling it a cash-grab and illegitimizing the band.  I guess I can understand the feeling somewhat.  The other member seemed to have more influence on the creative aspect of the band.  I guess the question then is, barring what happened here, is the album decent enough to stand on its own?  I think it is.  As I said, it is probably a much more standard-sounding black metal album, and if it were released under any other name, I do not think it would be met with as much hatred and vitriol as it had been.  I think what happened here, releasing this album under the name of a band its owner did not earn, is a shitty thing.  But I kind of like the album.  Maybe even as much as the other new one, though not as much as the original.